May 12, 2008 12:35 PM PDT

Welcome to the social mess?

Google Friend Connect, Facebook Connect, MySpace Data Availability, OpenID, DataPortability: Managing a bunch of different log-ins and passwords suddenly seems easy and straightforward.

Within a matter of days, some of the biggest names on the Web announced new projects that all have a roughly similar aim of making it possible for Web users to have a single social-media identity across the Internet--"data portability," as the general term has come to be known. MySpace.com was first out of the gate with the announcement of Data Availability, a way for members of the News Corp.-owned social network to share their profile data with partner sites including eBay, Yahoo, and Twitter. The next day, Facebook launched Facebook Connect, an extension of its developer API so that third-party sites can incorporate Facebook authentication and user identities.

The Google-created Friend Connect, announced Monday, is a little bit different. With its goal of bringing the connectivity of the social Web to its less social online brethren, the project takes a cue from two much lower-profile social-networking strategies: MyBlogLog, a Yahoo-acquired widget manufacturer that lets readers of popular blogs socialize with one another; and Flux, launched by Viacom to provide interoperable social features to its own Web sites but open to other participants as well.

Flux, developed by an old-media powerhouse that didn't exactly have much social-networking cred to fuel it, and start-up MyBlogLog, which thus far has failed to break out beyond the tech blog community, haven't been success stories (yet). Will having the world's biggest hubs of social networking and developer activity make the playing field any different? It's a positive sign that Google and MySpace have pledged to use open developer standards in their respective projects; Google, for instance, will take advantage of OpenID, OAuth, and the OpenSocial standard that it developed in-house before spinning it off as an independent organization. Facebook hasn't released technical details yet.

But one prominent data portability evangelist hinted that we're at an inflection point where the social Web could either become more connected or just more confusing.

"Any time that data becomes accessible, preferably with open standards, is a good move toward the open data portability vision," said Chris Saad, the entrepreneur spearheading the DataPortability Workgroup, a consortium of techies working toward the common goal of translating identities from one social site to another. "What's effectively happening now is that we are actually two or three steps closer toward doing proper interoperable data portability, but we all need to continue to work closely with those vendors and the rest of the community to make sure they evolve in the right direction."

Saad characterized the Facebook, Google, and MySpace announcements as "internal brands that are technically the beginning of a data portability play." All three companies have representatives in the DataPortability Workgroup, even though none of the week's announcements were developed in conjunction with the group.

"I don't think their job is done, and I don't think it's inevitable," Saad said. "We need to keep a watchful eye on the fact that these projects are actually evolving toward the best practices (of DataPortability) as opposed to trying to fragment the market."

One thing to keep in mind is that there's still time for all three of these projects to change and evolve before any Web users actually see them in action. Facebook is not yet at the point of releasing the technicalities of Facebook Connect other than the fact that it's an evolution of its existing API; MySpace's Data Availability is rolling out slowly with only a few launch partners. A general launch of Friend Connect, Google director of engineering David Glazer said, will take "months."

In the meantime, expect plenty of speculation, plenty of criticism of "walled gardens," and at least one claim that data portability is dead in the water before it's even taken off. This is tech blogging we're talking about--would you expect anything less?

Recent posts from The Social
'Facebook: The Movie': Now, who should play Mark Zuckerberg?
'Lonelygirl15' creators unveil new Web show, 'The Resistance'
Technorati acquires 'online magazine' Blogcritics
Reddit now lets you create your own social news site
Another nail in the 'Scrabulous' coffin
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 11 comments
by viperpack2029 May 12, 2008 1:22 PM PDT
What about PWNED.COM? it's blowing up like crazy as the largest social network for Gamers
Reply to this comment
by someguy999 May 12, 2008 3:55 PM PDT
maybe I'm missing something but hasn't live.com been open via their APIs for quite some time?

This is the greatest statement of the article "All three companies have representatives in the DataPortability Workgroup, even though none of the week's announcements were developed in conjunction with the group." I wish I could have bolded the work NONE. Too funny, in other words, "we all belong to this group, to say we do, but we're still doing our stuff OUR way".
Reply to this comment
by jabailo May 12, 2008 4:29 PM PDT
Those things have always been flops (Microsoft Passport, for example). This is an age of diversity and individualism...all these "Grand Unified Architectures" went out the window years ago.
Reply to this comment
by jabailo May 12, 2008 4:29 PM PDT
Those things have always been flops (Microsoft Passport, for example). This is an age of diversity and individualism...all these "Grand Unified Architectures" went out the window years ago.
Reply to this comment
by MyMesh_com May 12, 2008 6:46 PM PDT
Moving in the right direction, in any case.. just need more "portability" bits... ;-)
Reply to this comment
by sundance_tree May 12, 2008 8:04 PM PDT
its a good idea, a single identity (shared or otherwise), single sign on across many platforms means great and seamless user experience and because it's been initiated by companies whose users are used to accessing no nonsense experience (read: easy) then I think there'd be less or no resistance at all.
Reply to this comment
by The_Decider May 12, 2008 9:31 PM PDT
Good thing that "Grand Unified Architectures" went out the window years ago. Like Ethernet, TCP/IP, POP, FTP, etc.

Nothing like reinventing the wheel over and over and over again.
Reply to this comment
by The_Decider May 12, 2008 9:32 PM PDT
Who did CNET hire to ruin this site? Microsoft rejects? What a disgrace this fubared job is.
Reply to this comment View reply
by screenmachinetp May 13, 2008 1:42 AM PDT
And then there's Minggl; McCarthy, what say you about Minggl
Reply to this comment
by custompcmax May 13, 2008 3:46 AM PDT
Unless they get a fully unified system, these will never work. QUOTE: "MySpace.com was first out of the gate with the announcement of Data Availability, a way for members of the News Corp.-owned social network to share their profile data with partner sites including eBay, Yahoo, and Twitter." What happens if NEws Corp sells one of these? And are they planning on letting outside companies in? Or are they walling you off from other providers of information, etc...
Reply to this comment
Powered by Jive Software
advertisement

About The Social

CNET News' Caroline McCarthy is a downtown Manhattanite who believes that, despite popular opinion, the Web can actually help your social life. She's happily addicted to fun social-media tools from Twitter to Yelp to Facebook, sends an inordinate number of text messages, and has a tendency to waste time at the office reading restaurant blogs. Here, she explores all facets of the Web's gregarious side, as well as the unique tech culture in her home city of New York. (Don't call it Silicon Alley.)

Add this feed to your online news reader

The Social topics

Latest tech news headlines

Featured blogs

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right