• On GameSpot: Wii Fit tells 10-year-old she's fat
November 5, 2007 3:50 PM PST

Best phone ever: A Google phone wishlist

Posted by Nicole Lee
  • Print
Will Google's Android and the Open Handset Alliance result in the perfect phone?

Will Google's Android and the Open Handset Alliance result in the perfect phone?

(Credit: Open Handset Alliance)

One of the promises made with Google's new Android platform and the Open Handset Alliance is that we as consumers will finally be free from the tyranny of cell phone carriers. Thanks to Sprint and T-Mobile's agreement with the OHA philosophy of open and free cell phone usage, maybe we can finally truly find the perfect phone that'll match all our needs and be affordable at the same time.

But what does a perfect phone mean for me? Of course, right off the bat, I'm hoping for a compact device with generous screen real estate, a functional keypad or QWERTY keyboard, plus a 3-megapixel camera, but an open platform would not necessarily dictate the design of the hardware. So I'll focus mostly on software and desired features.

1) First and foremost, I want an easy to use OS. Sorry, Symbian and Windows Mobile--though both these mobile OSes have plenty of power, they're not the easiest for the smartphone newbie to understand. Palm is a fine OS, but it's getting to be rather dated and sadly underpowered. Ideally, the Android platform will be as easy to use as OS X on the iPhone, but with a lot more flexibility.

2) Google has already come to my aid with the second feature I want--the ability to install and use a wide range of applications. I would be happy with the Google apps alone--I use GMail and Google Calendar religiously, and Google Docs would be great to have--but if Google truly believes in the open-source movement, they would open the doors for their competitors to enter the gate as well. This means I want to see apps from Yahoo and Microsoft on here along with all the other third-party ones.

3) Following up on number 2, these are the applications I want on the phone: A fast and well-built browser that supports Flash as well as Java, a multiple IM client, an e-mail client that supports POP and IMAP, compatibility with Microsoft's Exchange server for work e-mail, and perhaps this is a pipe dream, but I want a VoIP client. Ideally, I'd like a mobile Skype app, as well as compatibility with something like T-Mobile's HotSpot @ Home, where I get to make free calls via WiFi.

4) It needs to be fast. That means I want 3G, and I want Wi-Fi as well (OK, so this is encroaching on hardware territory a bit). Thankfully, Qualcomm has mentioned that 3G will be a big part of Android, so this isn't too far from reality. That said, 3G and Wi-Fi together in one package would be ideal.

5) Open up Bluetooth as much as possible. That means I want stereo Bluetooth as well as the ability to tether my PC to the phone via Bluetooth and use it as a modem. This combined with the phone's 3G abilities would obviate the need for a separate EV-DO or HSDPA PC card.

That's a pretty hefty wishlist for sure, and I haven't even gone into the details yet. Perhaps there's a phone like this already and I'm not aware of it, but it would be nice to have Google's Android as well as the OHA produce something like this. I can guarantee you that if a well-designed phone comes out with all the above features and more, I might be willing to fork over my hard-earned cash for one.

How about you, dear readers? What is your ideal phone? And do you think the Android platform plus the OHA will come up with it? Let us know your thoughts in the comments section below.

P.S. OK, also, it'd be sweet if I could access my home computer while I'm on the road. All right, I'm done now.

Nicole Lee is an associate editor for CNET, covering cell phones, Bluetooth headsets, and all things mobile. She's also pretty geeky--she likes World of Warcraft, comic books, and shiny gadgets. E-mail Nicole.
Recent posts from Crave
Dead To Me, 'Little Brother': Free MP3 of the Day
Blogging from 25,000 feet
Video: 2010 Lexus RX450h
This week in Crave
Hearts Revolution, 'Switchblade': Free MP3 of the Day
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 16 comments
I am in agreement
by jmccrac1 November 6, 2007 8:00 AM PST
I agree with this post. I think it's silly that we've had to wait this long for something like that, but hopefully this android release will help to bring your's and a lot of other peoples dreams come true.
Reply to this comment
perhaps g. should team up with nokia, or someone..
by cariocadagema November 6, 2007 10:59 PM PST
Hi there,

I don't need a phone that pretends to be a camera, or an MP3 player, a GPS receiver or a computer. If it can run a thin e-mail client, so be it...

Apps I'll run at home/office on a number of specifically equipped machines. I carry a digital cam on my belt. I could take my Garmin where/whenever needed.

What I really want is a phone with a decent user interface, a battery that doesn't conk out halfway thru the day, and built solidly enough so that it ain't cross with me when I throw it at the wall (o.k. just kiddin')

Web browsing, spreadsheeting, doc management? What's the hurry - we need to reorganise our lives so as not to 'feel' we're alive only when on the ubiquitous umbilical e-cord!

BYW, this troglodyte built his first PC in 1982 and still has a strong penchant for tehcnology...

Cheers,

LMH
Reply to this comment
perhaps g. should team up with nokia, or someone..
by cariocadagema November 6, 2007 11:01 PM PST
Hi there,

I don't need a phone that pretends to be a camera, or an MP3 player, a GPS receiver or a computer. If it can run a thin e-mail client, so be it...

Apps I'll run at home/office on a number of specifically equipped machines. I carry a digital cam on my belt. I could take my Garmin where/whenever needed.

What I really want is a phone with a decent user interface, a battery that doesn't conk out halfway thru the day, and built solidly enough so that it ain't cross with me when I throw it at the wall (o.k. just kiddin').

Web browsing, spreadsheeting, doc management? What's the hurry - we need to reorganise our lives so as not to 'feel' we're alive only when on the ubiquitous umbilical e-cord!

BTW, this troglodyte built his first PC in 1982 and still has a strong penchant for technology...

Cheers,

LMH
Reply to this comment
Most popular software should be on g. phone
by Alexander.S November 7, 2007 5:01 AM PST
I suppose that new g. phone should have on it's board feature that are common to many customers such as free messangers: Yahoo, Skype, ICQ etc.
One very interesting feature could make the g.phone popular: Menu and View customization. So, the cumstomer could customize his phone as much as possible but using the phone features! Maybe macros based programing features, or some other tools on board would make the g.phone unique.

I wish success and wisdom to architects and developers team of new g.phone!

Cheers,
Alex.
Reply to this comment
Symbian....
by enoch861 November 7, 2007 6:03 AM PST
As u mentioned about skype and all you should check out Nokia's Internet Tablet. I actually think Google should team up with Nokia, because Nokia's phones are lighting up the future. Nokia's phones are I think the most Advanced phones on the planet.
Reply to this comment
Try the HTC 6800
by ebsktball30 November 7, 2007 6:33 AM PST
Basically all of the features that you are looking for in a "gphone" already exist in the HTC 6800. It has 3g and wife, bluetooth that supports stereo headsets and tethering to your pc (replaces of separate internet card). You can use VOiP with Skype, and you can even have remote desktop control via free Logmein software. The phone is capable of so many other things as well. Both Spring and Alltel carry it. I love mine.
Reply to this comment
what I need.....
by davelvb November 7, 2007 11:41 AM PST
The phones I crave must have voice activation for looking up phone numbers, dialing, addresses, and hopefully new voice activated ideas. here in California, we are under the gun to eliminate cell phone use while driving. if i were able to use voice activation for most everything on the phone, well......john law will not be looking at me.....
david
Reply to this comment
Go kick your editor
by coprophilous November 7, 2007 12:06 PM PST
Your article was interesting, your points valid, but this is simply poor:

"This combined with the phone's 3G abilities would obfuscate the need for a separate EV-DO or HSDPA PC card."

"Obfuscate" is what you did by using this word; "obviate" is the word you sought.
Reply to this comment
My Google Phone Wishlist:
by nikunjbhatt84 November 7, 2007 12:08 PM PST
Linux like OS (secure & based on C), but not so much complicated as
installing software in Linux is a tough task

TV,FM, and Radio channel receiver

GPS receiver

GSM and CDMA dual support

At least two Sim card simultaneously support

Multiple OS support

Upgradeable firmware

Multitype memory card slots

At least 2 mega pixel camera with flash

30 frame per second video recording

3.5 mm audio out jack

Nice voice recording

At least 65 k color display

Computer connection through Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, USB 2

2 keypad: QWERTY and normal phone keypad
Reply to this comment
Walkie Talkie
by bighouse1 November 7, 2007 2:35 PM PST
I just want to see it have walkie talkie capability.
Reply to this comment
Skype on the 'GPhone"
by tvtodd November 7, 2007 6:06 PM PST
E-bay is part of the Android consortium. THE SMARTEST thing that they could do is step forward and make Skype sing on the new OS. Make it as functional as the windows client, including all features, especially, wideband calling and voice quality.

E-bay could own the VOIP space with a move like this.....
Reply to this comment
answer ??
by uvikrama November 7, 2007 9:26 PM PST
have a look :-)

http://yankandpaste.blogspot.com/2007/11/maemo-answer-for-google-phone-wish-list.html

I dont even see nokia as a pertnet for google's effort where they already spend 3 yrs in this line.
Reply to this comment
This wish list sounds like my Mogul.
by ferrotus November 9, 2007 2:44 PM PST
My Mogul (Sprint) has most of these features. I love it. I also hate it. It has nowhere near enough memory. Also, it will not access about 10 - 15% of the web pages for which I ask and it needs a bigger battery or a supplementary battery pack to support the main battery. While 3g speed is nice, and a big improvement over excruciatingly slow, I want more, much more.
Reply to this comment
Another retarded cnet writer
by cardfan1212 November 10, 2007 7:50 AM PST
voip? who the heck cares. You're getting a phone to start with. It'd be downright stupid to include a feature not many care about.

wifi? Why? By the time this OS comes out EVDO and 3G will have evolved to even greater speeds. Wifi just isn't needed but i understand the wanting it. It's really not a feature i crave though.

That said, i understand you want it simple. You mentioned Palm OS meets this (it does) but then said its underpowered. Umm..for what? It does most of these features already that you seek so badly. Office apps? Audio/video? Recording? Stream internet radio? Full youtube? Tether a laptop? Watch slingbox? IM client? Stereo BT (with some software)? Hundreds of 3rd party apps?

Palm is creating a new OS which will probably address some of its shortcomings such as no wifi, finger touch, a full browser.

But again, your wishlist is stupid. That stuff is already here. Buy a 99 dollar Centro and be happy for now til Palm releases its new OS.
Reply to this comment
in philippines from california.
by liteyes November 11, 2007 10:42 PM PST
i want tv,cel,camera,telephone,web cam,calculator,notepad,phone book with photos attached,fast,simple..use on any nokia with 3g, dual sims working in all functions.simple too say,seems hard too do and under $250usd.hehee,impossible? u be rich u do it!
Reply to this comment
Is Android Better Than Windows Mobile?
by BabyDriver December 24, 2007 11:15 AM PST
That, to steal a phrase from Hamlet, is the question! And I've seen it being asked at places like http://www.androidvswindowsmobile.com. When you've got two such BIG players entering the mobile phone game (make it three with Apple's iPhone), there's a big clash o' the titans brewing? Who's going to win? Watching will be fun. Consumers could benefit!
Reply to this comment
advertisement

About Crave

The name says it all. Crave is our blog about gorgeous gadgets and other crushworthy stuff. If you would like to contact Crave with a tip or comment, please write to: crave@cnet.com

Add this feed to your online news reader

Crave topics

In the news now

Apple's iPhone 2.2
hits the street

The latest software update offers several improvements to Google maps as well as wireless downloading for podcasts.



The big chill for holiday parties?

Tech companies faced with cost-cutting may not be canceling the annual festivities outright, but things are certainly being done differently this year.



advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right