June 11, 2007 2:44 PM PDT

The smartest move in iPhone prehistory

The iPhone could be big. You heard it here first.

(Credit: James Martin/CNET News.com)

Today, during his keynote at WWDC 2007, Steve Jobs may have done the smartest thing in iPhone prehistory.

With two announcements that didn't receive any of the hype normally associated with the iPhone, Apple may have actually made good on its promise that the iPhone will be revolutionary. Much more revolutionary than pretty looks, a touch screen, a wide-screen iPod, or even visual voice mail.

So revolutionary, in fact, that it may have an impact on much more than just the mobile-phone industry. And they seemed so relatively unimportant at first glimpse...

The two smartest announcements in iPhone prehistory

1. A version of Apple's Safari browser has been released for Windows. (Download here.)

2. The "third-party iPhone apps" Steve Jobs alluded to weeks ago would be Web-based applications, not apps that run natively on the iPhone.

The second of these announcements sounded like a cop-out at first. After all, when Jobs mentioned opening the iPhone up to third-party applications, everyone got the impression he meant they'd actually run on the iPhone, not on a browser.

But here's why it looks so smart after a closer look.

Hedged bets Smart moves

1. Opening Safari to Windows is a great move for the development community. Windows developers can now test Web applications for Safari on Windows machines.

2. One of the iPhone's drawing points is that it runs a full browser (albeit one that won't support Java and possibly won't support Flash), and the iPhone hype machine promises an unparalleled browsing experience for a mobile device.

3. Because Safari is the application platform for the iPhone, Safari on Windows creates a much bigger pool of developers for the iPhone than releasing an SDK would. Making any site "iPhone-compatible" will be the hip thing to do, and developing for a touch screen device could unleash some serious creativity. (Think of the possibilities for porn! Glorious, touch-interactive porn!)

4. Non-native apps also means that iPhone users won't need to download packages or install software. This could be a significant factor for a device that only has 4GB or 8GB of storage (and a lot of songs and videos competing for that space).

5. Web-based apps running on Safari creates no additional security issues for the iPhone. Your iPhone will be as secure as Safari is.

6. Because the apps are Web-based, they are cross-platform by nature. But if you run them on the iPhone, you get a little something extra: a touch screen interface. During the keynote, VP of iPhone software Scott Forstall mentioned that Web applications will "know" they're running on an iPhone and act accordingly. Java's "write once, run anywhere" mantra may be perfected by the iPhone (ironically, a device that purportedly won't run Java).

So maybe, just maybe, the iPhone will be revolutionary on quite a few fronts. At the very least, it may reprioritize some things.

The iPhone's impact on the Web

1. Immediately, Web developers have an exciting new platform to create applications for, and the iPhone's touch screen is a fun interface to think about when creating new applications.

2. This may kick-start Web 2.0's evolution into Web 3.0: sites and services redefined, redesigned, and refined for a handheld platform and fully mobile user base.

3. As competing devices follow suit and shift to a more immersive mobile browsing experience, Web-based software and Web 2.0 sites may have great days ahead of them.

Even for someone who despises the iPhone hype, these announcements are pretty exciting. Apple seems to have mastered the art of declaring itself innovative, and the combined power of the development community and the mass appeal of the iPhone could lead to true innovation. It's good for the iPhone, good for Web 2.0, good for mobile devices, good for developers, and good for users.

But...is it still smart to buy an iPhone?

Alas, some of the iPhone's perceived shortcomings may also become magnified by a cottage industry of third-party Web applications.

1. With such a reliance on Web-based apps, EDGE seems like a terrible decision over 3G networks.

2. Wi-Fi is still in the iPhone's bag of tricks, but let's hope the battery life can take the added pressure.

3. The touch screen-only UI could become a burden for keyboard-intensive apps.

What do you think? Huge news, cop-out 2.0, or somewhere in between? Let us know in the TalkBack section below.

Recent posts from Webware
Why can't they fix the Flash/Firefox bug?
Get remote file access, management on your iPhone with Sugarsync
Patents.com lets you search through ideas (good and bad)
Exploring Internet Explorer 8
Accounting on the go: Quickbooks for iPhone and Blackberry
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 42 comments (Showing first 20 comments)
You have lost a daily reader.
by GoodSiteList June 11, 2007 4:17 PM PDT
Mr. Needleman,

I have loved the information you have shared on current innovations of Webware with us for so long, but after reading you comment in this article about "porn" you have lost me as a daily reader and I will no longer refer my friends to your blog. I am disappointed that a person of such influence as yourself would be a proponent of porn instead of being a proponent of cleaning up all the filth on the web. One app you should really take a look at, with your wife, is K9 Web Filter and encourage people to use that not to get more and more involved with life destroying filth we call "porn" that has spread around the world like a plague destroying so many lives and marriages around the world.

GoodSiteList
Reply to this comment View all 8 replies
It was no the word "porn" but the full statement
by GoodSiteList June 11, 2007 5:09 PM PDT
I was not referring to the use of the term "porn" as being what makes you a proponent but I just didn't want to repeat your full statement, but here it is: "Think of the possibilities for porn! Glorious, touch-interactive porn!" If this statement is not glorifying porn I do not know what is.

I would also like to apologize to Mr. Needleman for addressing the comment to him. I was not aware it wasn't him that wrote it.

GoodSiteList
Reply to this comment View all 3 replies
I love it.
by John the Geek June 11, 2007 5:45 PM PDT
I don't think many people have paid any attention to the connection between
Safari for Windows and iPhone developement. I keep hearing "Why?" and it's all
too clear to me. It's the SDK they all wanted!

Great article. Considering all of the fantastic widgets people have made for
dashboard I can't wait to see what people make for the iPhone.
Reply to this comment
Good, but they're not the only one
by ctfoley June 11, 2007 6:41 PM PDT
Web apps are good, but I can't imagine Safari becoming standard at all. Firefox is already halfway there, why reinvent the wheel?
Reply to this comment View reply
Real third party apps!
by Wraith_X June 12, 2007 2:45 AM PDT
Hmm - it was obvious web based apps like Google Reader would work any way
through Safari so I don't see how this is opening up the iPhone to third party
developers.

I would be most excited about seeing revolutionary Mac/Windows software like
The Filter ( http://www.thefilter.com ) on the little touchscreen
box.
Reply to this comment
The BIG picture
by D_Acuff June 12, 2007 5:31 AM PDT
Well, I want an I-Phone, and I would plan to get one, right after I get a Play Station III, oh wait, I can't afford that either. lol.

Look the BIG news here is that the Safari browser is available on Windows!! Millions of developers will now be able to cater to the Mac crowd. Those of us who either don't own macs and/or who work for companies that do not readily have Mac's around can now test on Safari. In general this is not a big issue, as if your a decent Modern coder and cross-check in IE/Firefox your code is golden in Safari, but there are always cases where you get unexpected results is Safari. This is one small step for Apple, on giant leap for mankind.
Reply to this comment
are you serious?
by istev June 12, 2007 7:59 AM PDT
Hmm..I am not so excited about another browser, if it means that it creates more problems and greater exposure to threats.
Listed on CNet's home page today -
http://news.com.com/8301-10784_3-9728500-7.html?part=rss&tag=feed&subj=NewsBlog&tag=cnetfd.blog

No 3G? No KB? No push email? No thanks.

Wifi? great if I want to sit at home and use my phone, though I rather use my laptop/desktop and view the web on large screen. If there was the possibility of calls via wifi (like skype for windows mobile or TMO's uma), there might be a draw.

Google apps? great. But Windows Live Search is pretty solid and simple to use.

I'm not about to criticize something thats not even available, but I don't see what all the excitement is about.
Reply to this comment View reply
Don't miss the iPod hiding in there!!!
by bthathaway June 12, 2007 8:22 AM PDT
With all the focus on the phone part of the new handheld device, I think we're missing the bigger picture. Over and over Steve Jobs says that they have created the best *iPod* ever with this unit. Let's say that again--this is the best *iPod* they've ever made.

So what happens this Fall when they start selling the iPod only version of this handheld? How likely that they keep the WiFi and the browser capabilities??? If so, then you have a tremendous platform to roll out all sorts of web apps to millions of users and of course Apple will be at the head of the line with iTunes. Don't tell me that won't revolutionize online retailing of all sorts.

I don't know whether the iPhone will make all that big a difference in this world. Probably not. But a world filled with browser enabled iPods??? Add in some digital wallet technology??? What about a little GPS in a future generation??? Use your iPod to lead you through online and bricks and mortar purchases. Now THAT's exciting.

I can't wait to see the new iPods. That's where Apple really takes off.

BT
Reply to this comment
What the-?
by Gamut June 12, 2007 4:02 PM PDT
Your views seem a little skewed to me. Pornography is a wonderful outlet for sexual frustration and, in fact, helps millions of people re-amplify their sexual relationships. Unfortunately, there is some content which is undeniably reprehensible such as child porn, incest, people recording rape (and in my personal opinion scat porn...nasty); however, general pornography is not only legal, but a fantastic way to practice sexual health. Like it or not, porn is here to stay; and it's more than likely to get more and more common. So do yourself a favor and get used to it!
Reply to this comment View reply
Wrong MOVE! Should have gone with Firefox!
by salimmadjd June 12, 2007 6:35 PM PDT
Safari on PC is a horrible idea. Safari on Mac is a biggest nightmare for developers (at least for us) and now to deal with it on the PC as well. Don't get me wrong I like apple and all, but I wish they would completely build on top of FF instead of releasing yet another browser.

It would have been a big news if Iphone would run FF and most web application would just run with little tweak or non at all. Now that would be big. But to make us support safari. What's the point? If safari was meant to ease the creation of iphone application, then why not go all the way and just use FF that has a larger usage and is better understood by the developers.
Reply to this comment View reply
All my future apps will be iPhone friendly
by joepwro June 12, 2007 7:25 PM PDT
I think the iPhone crosses a threshold on portable devices that are truely Internet enabled. All future apps from my company will be iPhone ready - it what manager want.
Reply to this comment
The smartest move in iPhone pre-history
by Hope M. June 12, 2007 10:56 PM PDT
The Iphone that would be available for public use in June 29, has made a lot of noise latyely, it is because of the revolutionary changes that it has given to the rest of the world. It could not really denied that wer could notice that all over the world the Iphone would converging 3 distinct media apps., so on the part of the public, they should test the capability of the device, better use it in front of a capacity crowd screaming...let's discuss this further, reach me at
http://forum.affiliatebot.com/register.php
Reply to this comment
The smartest move in iPhone pre-history
by Hope M. June 12, 2007 10:57 PM PDT
The Iphone that would be available for public use in June 29, has made a lot of noise latyely, it is because of the revolutionary changes that it has given to the rest of the world. It could not really denied that wer could notice that all over the world the Iphone would converging 3 distinct media apps., so on the part of the public, they should test the capability of the device, better use it in front of a capacity crowd screaming...let's discuss this further, reach me at
http://forum.affiliatebot.com/register.php
Reply to this comment
Get Your Collective Minds Out of the Gutter
by schneb` June 13, 2007 8:16 AM PDT
What is it with people? Any time any new piece of technology comes out, the first thing you think of is porn? I guess the movie Brainstorm had mankind pretty much pegged.
Reply to this comment View all 2 replies
Unprofessional
by schneb` June 13, 2007 8:21 AM PDT
Yes, you may have rationalized porn in your own life. The point is, it has NO business in a technology article. C/Net is a business, and placing such comments in an article is unprofessional and would get me fired at my job--and probably yours.
Reply to this comment View all 3 replies
by Essays March 19, 2008 9:25 AM PDT
Great post. I recommend Peer Papers for researching. They have over 100,000 term papers and essays available on almost every subject.
Reply to this comment
 See all 42 Comments >>
Powered by Jive Software
advertisement

About Webware

Say No to boxed software! The future of applications is online delivery and access. Software is passé. Webware is the new way to get things done.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Webware topics

advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right