top stories

Rant

Where are the big ideas?

Right now, a small team with no money can start a real online business. If the founders are very lucky, they generate revenue and begin to grow. If they are exceptionally fortunate, they get sold to Google for $1.65 billion. But most of the start-ups we cover on Webware.com will languish for a while in obscurity and eventually die. The problems they are solving are not big enough.

This is one of the reasons that venture capitalists are having a hard time. Many are are sitting on funds of hundreds of millions of dollars, looking for places to put large chunks of that money. But you can't put more than a few hundred thousand into a typical Web start-up without drowning it in funds it can't use. Over-funding a company can kill it, just as surely as starving it of resources.

This is a problem, because if a business can be funded by credit card debt, a competitor can come in and start the same business, and undercut whatever profit margin the first business is relying on to keep the Ramen cupboard stocked. Big businesses have defensive walls around them, and often these walls are built with stacks of money.

These are the businesses that I really like--big plays that take big money and major industry expertise to start. If they work, they change the landscape.

The bigger the If, the better. And these are businesses that the VCs are salivating for. While it's possible for Web entrepreneurs to build nice earners funded only by debt, the efficient start-up economy is pushing the big VC money into energy, transportation, and health care.

But there are interesting Web ideas that require big funding. For example: Earth Class Mail (review). This company takes postal mail, digitizes it, and sends it to customers electronically. For it to work at a large scale, it requires industrial scanners, sorting equipment, warehouses for storage, and so on. You can't start this company in your basement.

See also: RevolutionMoney. Steve Case (co-founder of AOL) is creating a new credit card. Competing with Visa can't be done cheaply.

Or: Powerset (preview). This company is trying to revolutionize Internet search by applying semantic analysis to the same billions of pages that Google has done only lightweight link analysis on. Powerset's method is computationally intense and very expensive.

Are the above businesses great ideas? They might be, but that's not the point. The point is that they are big bets with big buy-ins. These companies will have limited business competition simply because it costs more to play in their leagues. It's companies like this that attract the big venture money--money that's desperately looking for a place to work.

It's great that so much can be done today for so little. But that shouldn't stop entrepreneurs from also going for the really big scores. To win big, bet big.

 
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 9 Comments (Page 1 of 1)
by pmizota December 10, 2007 3:36 PM
I think there is a lack of big ideas because I believe there is a fundamental disconnect between the currently liquidity climate for start-ups and the VC funding model. Rather than take up a lot of space, I've posted more details on my blog at http://abovethenoise.blogspot.com/2007/12/where-are-big-ideas.html.
Reply to this comment
by rafe December 10, 2007 4:21 PM
@pmizota you are certainly right, the exits are not nearly as open for VC-funded startups as they used to be. But it won't remain like this forever. Big companies take time to build. Couldn't liquidity become possible for companies started today that become IPO-ready in, say, five years?
Reply to this comment
by Familyresource4u December 11, 2007 6:05 AM
Excellent post! I started my website with $200 and want to solve one of the biggest problems on the web. The web is getting larger and larger. Good information are buried in the spams, so so blogs, ads and many copy cat websites. My goal is to dig the best information on the web and put all in one place. A lot of these have to be done as a research topic and many work need to be done. Even the simple problem, how to clean the coffee stain, I search all information on the web, very few satisfactory solutions. My goal is to make my website as one stop information on career, family, education, technology etc. Http://web500.us
Reply to this comment View reply
by essell December 12, 2007 6:15 AM
Big Ideas are out there, just not so much in the web world. The web is needed however to make any big idea work. Take for instance, the housing initiative being put forward by Ayess, where they have developed a mass production housing idea. It'll take hundreds of milions to get it launched, but when they were highlighted by Fast Company it certainly created a lot of buzz. Not sure if any VC's picked up on it or not as I haven't done any additional research, but it's a huge idea.
Reply to this comment
by dlock December 12, 2007 12:03 PM
This post really caught my eye, for a couple reasons. First, our web site / startup (http://www.ThoughtOffice.com) is completely self-funded, and secondly, it's dedicated to developing new ideas, both big & small. I have to agree. Solving the big problems today does take a lot of cash. I think it's partly because the solutions have to cover so much figurative ground, or require the construction of an expensive infrastructure. One example might be municipal wireless Internet. The ROI on muni WiFi isn't immediately obvious, and may be some time coming. It's not easy to get people to invest in long-term projects. Deep-pocketed VCs and companies like Google are going to be the ones to fund new, vital programs like this.
Reply to this comment
by WHlanteigne December 12, 2007 11:19 PM
Great ideas abound, the problem is connecting them to capital. Off the top of my head, with respect to transportation, the obvious need is for a light, 100+ mpg single or two seat commuter car than I can drive to work in any weather: something more than a motor scooter, but less than a car, a microcar or enclosed trike, priced to sell for around $8,000. Auto X-prize contender, for sure. A Carver for the price of a Kia? Ideally it would handle like a Lotus 7. The real challenge is marketing: convincing Joe or Jane Suburb to park the SUV during the week and drive the commuter (my discussion group calls it a "cabin scooter") to work.
Reply to this comment
by WHlanteigne December 23, 2007 8:56 PM
Non-radiative wireless energy transfer. Miles-long coils imbedded in roadways used to power electric vehicles, extending range and reducing the size of the battery pack. A pickup coil on the bottom of the vehicle would pick up energy from the imbedded roadway coils. Wireless energy transfers already exist in limited applications; the challenge is not so much technical, but in devising a method of measuring the amount of energy used, identifying and billing the user. Huge investment required for R&D, enormous potential payoff.
Reply to this comment View reply
Powered by Jive Software