top stories

Kiss Microsoft Project goodbye

If you use Microsoft Project, you might want to seriously consider three alternatives that run completely on the Web. In addition to supporting more contemporary features right now, and getting updated with even newer gadgets more frequently than Microsoft can muster, these products, being completely Web-based, offer much more robust collaboration tools.

First up: Liquid Planner. We saw this product at Demo 2008 but it will be on stage again at the Under the Radar conference that I'm moderating on Thursday. This tool's special sauce is its embrace of uncertainty. Users can put in best-case and worst-case estimates for their tasks, and the product combines all the estimates to tell you how likely you are to make deadlines, and also which sub-tasks are the most critical to achieving project goals.

Then there's Clarizen, the 2.0 version of which comes out this week. This product has a very nice, very Web 2.0 user interface, but what I like best about it that most users will never see the UI: managers can set up projects on the Clarizen site, but people responsible for delivering on those projects never have to use it. The product sends e-mail queries that users can update directly, bypassing the main site and the $50 monthly per-user fee as well.

Finally, there's the specialized Mumboe, which we'll also see at Under the Radar. This is a Web-based "CLM" (contract lifecycle management) app, but it's apparently one of the first to have a completely free subscription tier. The tool tracks the documents that go into a business agreement, and lets you specify start and end dates, deliverables, commitments, and tracking metrics. You can delegate tasks, of course, and also see your entire list of deliverables and commitments on one dashboard screen. Mumboe will also be at Under the Radar.

Join me at Under the Radar!

I stink at project management and can't offer an expert opinion on these products, but I do think that if you are a project management software user, you might want to try one of these Web-based tools. Of course, don't forget to also check out Basecamp.

Add a Comment (Log in or register) 20 comments (Page 1 of 2)
by quickbase March 18, 2008 6:59 AM PDT
I would recommend that you also check out or review QuickBase. It's online application platform that basically let's you build your own collaborative web application. But even if building one doesn't strike your fancy, you can use one of the pre-built web apps for things like project management. Link: http://quickbase.intuit.com
Reply to this comment View reply
by tom Termini March 18, 2008 12:30 PM PDT
Project management is crying out for web-based collaboration. But what about the other aspects of data and information knowledge workers need to incorporate into the work process? Moving a knowledge-based organization towards the Kaizen goal of continuous improvement calls for integrated tools. The software-as-a-service model is an excellent value for small-to-medium (SME) organizations who want the same tools as the big boys, but at a per-seat or transaction-based price. http://www.bluedog.net/workbench is a prime example.
Reply to this comment
by MadLyb March 18, 2008 3:48 PM PDT
I have to disagree with your suggestions. While I welcome the competition to an excellent, but aging product, the reality is storing Project Management data that may contain sensitive information outside the firewall is just not going to happen.
Reply to this comment
by Jim Nielsen March 18, 2008 4:02 PM PDT
To comment on only three when there are over a dozen SaaS, web-based offerings in this category is a bit of a disservice. Take a look at this comparison for a better glimpse of what they can actually do: http://project-management-software-review.toptenreviews.com/ or even this site http://blog.softwareprojects.org/top-10-project-management-software-websites-32.html . I have been in project management for over 20 years, and MS Office is a default because it started out cheaper, and you had to give up a lot that the others already had - like Project Workbench. Speaking of, check out the REAL MS PROJECT KILLER - back for a second life, it is the all new, open source version of PWB: http://www.openworkbench.org/images/stories/Articles/pmi-open-workbench.pdf
Reply to this comment
by harrismoin March 18, 2008 4:11 PM PDT
broken link for basecamp ... correct link is http://www.basecamphq.com/
Reply to this comment
by JakeCamp12 March 18, 2008 4:23 PM PDT
Why not use a real scheduling tool like the one made by Primavera Systems called Primavera 6.0? Project has been garbage since they started selling it. At least with Primavera 6.0 you get a true critical path method schedule.
Reply to this comment
by treet007 March 18, 2008 7:17 PM PDT
Project management (PM) and contract management are not the same thing, so to recommend Mumboe as a PM tool is too hasty. There are also different plugins for Microsoft Project, such as Critical Chain method of scheduling (http://sphericalangle.com/), which still makes MS Project relevant. Finally, if the project schedule and resource management are being administered in a Program Management Office (PMO), the PM scheduling tools have to support PMO backend systems to upload/download PM information, so these Internet-based PM tools won't just cut it in a PMO environment.
Reply to this comment
by heimangil March 18, 2008 10:59 PM PDT
By the way, Clarizen will also be at Under the Radar this week, presenting as part of the Graduate Circle. For those who think that companies won't embrace SaaS based business solutions due to firewall concerns, we'll be happy to put you in touch with some of our big and small customers who have crossed the chasm and are reaping the advantages of a hosted AND secure solution.
Reply to this comment
by onlineadministration March 19, 2008 2:24 AM PDT
Just to let you know that the basecamp address is wrong its www.basecamphq.com thanks - great article though
Reply to this comment
by mihaione March 19, 2008 2:29 AM PDT
Try BlueAnt from Proventis. It's fully web-based and has all the PPM collaborative functions you need and more (Gantt chart, resources allocation, etc.). http://www.proventis.net/website/live/index_en.html
Reply to this comment
1 | 2 | Next 10 Comments >>
Powered by Jive Software
advertisement
Click Here.

New to Web 2.0?

Check out the Webware Newbie's Guides:

Facebook | Twitter | Flickr | Google RSS | Flock
advertisement

Webware

Webware

COOL WEB 2.0 APPS FOR EVERYONE

CNET
Visit other CNET Networks sites: