top stories

Awards,

And the Webware 100 winners are...

I'm happy to announce the winners of the 2008 Webware 100. These are the 100 top Web apps, 10 each in 10 categories, according to Webware users and the fans of the products that were finalists in the awards.

You can see all the winners in one place, or page through the winners one-by-one in the Webware 100 Navigator.

Over 1.9 million votes were cast for the 300 finalists this year. These finalists were selected (by Webware editors) from a pool of over 5000 qualifying nominees. But the 100 winners were selected by popular vote. These winning 100 products represent the best of the Web, according the people who use it.

Voting overview

As with the 2007 awards, the majority of votes, 88% this year, were cast for winning products. Of the ten categories, the most popular in terms of votes cast was Browsing. However it's worth noting that one of the entries in that category, Maxthon, drove an inordinate amount of votes by putting a vote-driving popup in the software itself. Even after we had the popup removed, though, Maxthon easily garnered a winning number of votes.

If you subtract the initial Maxthon Effect votes from Browsing, by far the most voted-in category was Social, just like last year. And again, Gaia Online got the most votes in the category. However, competition in this space is heating up. Gaia's 136,000 votes, while well ahead of the 91,000 it won last year, represented only 34% of the votes cast in the Social category, compared to 60% last year.

Just slightly more than half of all the votes cast in the Webware 100 went to the top 10 vote-getters. Six of these top 10 are no surprise at all: Facebook, Firefox, Google, iTunes, MySpace, and YouTube. But the other four may not be as familiar to most Webware readers:

    • DeviantArt. A strong online arts community.

    • Friendster. A social network that was big, became small, and may be making a resurgence.

    • Gaia Online. A graphical social networking site for teenagers. As I said, a big winner in last year's Webware 100.

    • Maxthon. It's a browser that's huge in China, not so much here in the US.

The least active voting category was Productivity (64,000 votes), but the winning product with the smallest number of votes was, to my surprise, the useful and popular Zillow, in the Commerce category. It got 1,095 votes. Unlike last year, there were no winners with fewer than 1,000 votes. The average number of votes per winner: 16,675.

Repeats and disappointments

Many of the winners this year were also Webware 100 winners last year, although the tough competition did knock some of last year's winners off the list (thankfully, otherwise the results would be quite boring). Next year we'll do more to give startups and new products a chance to win an award.

I was surprised to see Digg not garner a winning number of votes. Likewise Plaxo and Ning, two strong companies with active social networks.

And personally, I really wanted Blist (review), which is brand new, to win an award, but being great isn't enough to win a popular vote -- you have to be known.

Rafe's Top 10

We kept editorial influence out of the Webware 100 voting, but now that the results are in, I can pick my favorites of the winners. My criteria: Useful, interesting, fun, or some killer combination. And not the same thing that everyone else will pick (Google, Flickr, Facebook, etc.). Here they are:

    • Picasa Web Albums. A pale shadow of Flickr in terms of buzz and community, but solid integration with Google's desktop photo app Picasa makes it a great place to publish photos designed for limited distribution, like friends and family.

    • Meebo. The multi-IM client we've always wanted, now in handy browser format. Also has its own platform, the Meebo API, and powers public chats for several big sites. Worth watching.

    • Miro. An open-source media player and organizer, it very nearly gives iTunes a run for its money, except that it doesn't sell annoying DRM'd content.

    • uStream. The innovative live video streaming company. There are several imitators now, but uStream continues to power several geek (and other) Internet broadcasters.

    • Twitter. The people who laugh at Twitter do not understand it. Pity them.

    • RememberTheMilk. Handles the simple job of keeping your to-do list, but does it better than other similar apps while at the same time offering a ridiculous number of features to improve the experience.

    • FotoFlexer. One of a group of online photo editors (see also, Picnik, not a Webware 100 winner) that is redefining what you can do on the Web.

    • OpenID. The one-signon-for-all-sites standard continues to gain momentum. The OpenID concepts are still too foreign for most consumers to get, but the sites supporting OpenID keep making it simpler. Could easily become the Web-wide universal login within two years.

    • Etsy. A beautiful marketplace for handcrafted goods. Bonus: It's also a great place to find craftspeople who will make just what you want them to make.

    • And finally, my guily pleasure: Woot. This is the Home Shopping Network for geeks. Addicting, clever, and occasionally it even has good deals.

What do you think?

Each of the Webware 100 winner pages has an open comment thread. We're using Disqus, our favorite comment system, to run this. Unlike posts on the rest of Webware.com, you don't have to register to leave your feedback on the Webware 100 winner pages. So go wild.

 
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 10 Comments (Page 1 of 1)
by TaraKelly April 21, 2008 12:20 PM
Congratulations to all the winners, from the PassPack team! It was really exciting to be selected into the same category as Amazon, Yahoo! & friends by the Webware staff. Thanks to all and enjoy the festivities at WebExpo2.0! - Tara PassPack Founding Partner
Reply to this comment
by cflorig April 21, 2008 2:25 PM
Finally the wait is over! Last year's list was so great, I just couldn't wait for this year's results. I totally agree with RememberTheMilk...I actually had a reminder today to check on the results. Looking forward to checking out all the winners!
Reply to this comment
by Familyresource4u April 22, 2008 5:43 AM
I use many of these sites and most of them are great. But there are two real disappoints: Farecast and smugmug, which used regularly are not here! http://web500.us
Reply to this comment
by kevinss April 22, 2008 9:45 AM
A great contest, but I would have to agree that it was heavily weighed toward big names for not only recognition factor, but also in the ability of the big groups to self promote on their heavily viewed sites. That said, I think it was very hard for smaller, unique web 2.0 technologies like our Bubble Guru platform to get viewers to review our service at all. A standout, perhaps smaller side contest would have been good for Webware viewers to really review and learn about some of the lesser known web 2.0 apps that have emerged this past year, as it's hard to vote accurately, if you don't have all the facts in hand. That said, still a great contest, and thanks for running it!
Reply to this comment
by WrnEgaid April 22, 2008 3:01 PM
Reviewing the Webware winners reminded me of an old time saying, "Sometimes the good die young". What started out as an event to recognize novel, creative, informative, and useful web sites has ended in a facade. I don?t see 100 web sites, I see one. One great big commercialized blob where ?winners? as you call them, are nothing more than a ranking of businesses who financially support cnet by their advertising dollars. I can recall when cnet focused on the sciences and new technologies. However today, it has become nothing more than a marketing tool.
Reply to this comment
by Seattle John April 23, 2008 9:07 AM
Congratulations to all of the winners. For me, the best part of the contest was that I found a lot of new sites to explore. Keep up the good work.
Reply to this comment
by alanllevy April 23, 2008 6:03 PM
BlogTalkRadio is honored to be chosen as one of the Webware 100 companies. Thanks to the Rafe and the Webware team for coordinating this program.
Reply to this comment
by Ideaworks April 26, 2008 8:15 AM
The Navigator Bar has a glitch and drops through on Hotmail to the site itself. Excellent tool otherwise to give folks an overview of the winners. Thank you so much. I'll forward the Navigator Bar once the glitch is fixed. - Bob
Reply to this comment
by Ron White April 27, 2008 11:27 AM
Rafe Needleman?s description of the voting for the Webware 100 Awards unfortunately gives a false impression of the circumstances surrounding the votes Maxthon received in the browser category. Rafe writes: ?Of the ten categories, the most popular in terms of votes cast was Browsing. However it's worth noting that one of the entries in that category, Maxthon, drove an inordinate amount of votes by putting a vote-driving popup in the software itself.? The problem is that word ?inordinate.? It suggests that Maxthon didn?t deserve all the votes it received. To set the record straight, here are the events that led up to Maxthon garnering more than 400,000 votes, about a fourth of all the votes cast in the Webware contest among all 100 winning products. When Maxthon was chosen as a finalist for the award, Needleman wrote us, ?Starting on February 25, you can encourage your users and fans to vote for your product ?.? There was no qualification on how we could encourage users to vote; we could have hired the Goodyear blimp or bought advertising time on American Idol. We chose to put links to the voting site on a few of Maxthon?s pages and on a pop-up we sometimes use for such things as news and wishing users a Merry Christmas. The hitch in the process occurred when David Lenehan, the CEO of PollDaddy, the company tallying the votes, walked into his server room to be greeted by flashing lights and screaming alarms. The Maxthon votes, coming in at a rate as high as 100 votes for ever y .01 seconds, had brought down his servers. Lenehan, in Ireland, got in touch with Maxthon CEO Jeff Chen in Beijing through Skype chat. After hearing Chen?s explanation of how Maxthon was promoting itself for the contest, Lenehan said, ?There is nothing wrong with what you did. ? There is nothing wrong with your votes. ?Going b y the vote count I don?t think you guys actually need any more votes,? he added. Chen agreed to the solution Lenehan proposed: taking the contest link off the news pop-up. ?Although we want more users to know, I also don't want to take trouble to your system,? Chen said. After the pop-up was deactivated, votes for Maxthon continued to pour in. After the contest, Needleman wrote Chen, ? I do owe you a big thanks: 6% of the Maxthon voters also cast votes for other Webware 100 finalists, and we really do appreciate the traffic and the visibility.? What it comes down to is that Maxthon is a damn good browser, its users reflect that fact with their enthusiastic support, and a vote is a vote is a vote. Anyone who has doubts that Maxthon deserves to be in the Top Ten of all vote getters for the Webware 100 Awards only has to download a copy at http://maxthon.com/download.htm to find out for themselves. Ron White
Reply to this comment
by kamas808 May 1, 2008 1:33 PM
Netvibes.com and Firefox should have won.
Reply to this comment
Powered by Jive Software