Security Starter Kit

With a new year comes new computers, and that means new security problems. Viruses, spyware, rootkits, hackers--a fresh machine can be susceptible to the most insidious of plots. Lucky for you, here in the CNET Download.com defense bunker, we've devised a list of essential and free top-rated security programs to protect the honor of your computer and ensure that your sanity will last longer than your resolutions.
Categories covered include Firewall, Antivirus, Spyware remover, Web-surfing adviser, Parental control, Pop-up blocker, and Encryption.
Comodo Firewall Pro has eradicated most of its resource-hogging ways and gives users what they want: a flexible yet simple firewall that's great for beginners but also provides a smorgasbord of information and plenty of options for advanced users.

Comodo Firewall Pro
From the category tabs of Summary, Firewall, Defense +, and Miscellaneous to more specific headings, most security terms come linked to relevant security issues so users can drill down to learn more about how the firewall is performing. Although the app rears its head often when you first fire it up, once it learns your behavior, it becomes virtualy unnoticeable.
AVG Anti-Virus Free Edition provides all the necessities to destroy infections, including tools for scanning your hard drive and e-mail, as well as a real-time shield to prevent infections.
By default, it's set to update new virus definitions daily, but you always can use the scheduler to change this. Should a virus create serious system problems, AVG creates a rescue disk to scan your computer in MS-DOS mode. The program doesn't tax your system when scanning or when running in the background and always proved effective in our tests. The interface isn't pretty, but it isn't hard to navigate, either.
Avira Antivir does double-duty, protecting against spyware and viruses alike. For users who want backups or want to have their antivirus and antispyware separate, we've recommended alternatives. Antivir's scans are flexible, allowing the user to check all hard drives, choose a preloaded scan--for rootkits, for example--or customize. After testing on several machines, no viruses turned up, although several malicious hidden files did rear their heads. The heuristic scan can be turned on or off completely or partially, with three different intensity levels.

Avira AntiVir
The quarantine offers extensive support, too, although the definition file updater can be sluggish. Still, combining effective antimalware and antivirus tools into one is a freeware luxury.
The tiny Trend Micro HijackThis examines vulnerable or suspect parts of your system and scrubs them clean of whatever malfeasance has infected them. It can be a complicated program to use, but also one that's extremely effective.
After a scan, don't check off an item and hit the Fix Checked button unless you're sure it's malware. Clicking Info will tell you why the entry was flagged, but to learn if it's malware you need to search the Web or check out a forum such as SpywareInfo or Computer Cops. Saving the log creates a text document you can post to these forums. HijackThis is a serious tool for any user who needs to root out a serious infestation, but wield it with caution.
McAfee SiteAdvisor for Firefox and Internet Explorer warns you about covert spyware and browser-hijack attempts as you visit a site.

McAfee SiteAdvisor
It operates as an unobtrusive signal in your browser's interface, turning green if the site is safe, yellow if it's suspect, and red if it senses threats. The same system applies to search results, inserting a colored icon next to each link. Clicking one provides threat diagnostics, including links to suspect sites, spam counts, and dangerous downloads. In our tests, SiteAdvisor turned out accurate and reliable results, and though it doesn't have a wide array of features, we encourage all users to try this extension.
K9 Web Protection provides many options for customizing your remote Web supervision needs, but also comes with a handful of predesigned filters. With more than 50 categories for organizing Web sites, and a keyword-free rating system, the Web monitoring and blocking aspects of the software functioned well. Equally impressive--and a little bit scary--was the log that detailed not just blocked Web sites but also every Web site visited.
Installation and removal isn't easy: Be prepared for a multistep process. K9 does lack a chatware filter, leaving some holes for predation.
No matter which browser you use, Pop-up Stopper Free Edition has you covered. You can specify different sound and text-bubble alarms or set your mouse to change colors when the program blocks a pop-up ad. Unlike some of its ilk, this utility doesn't affect the Open in New Window right-click context-menu command. You can allow individual pop-up windows by holding the Ctrl or Shift key.
The one drawback to the free edition is that it limits your configuration options and doesn't let you specify pop-ups you want to always allow. Despite those drawbacks, Pop-Up Stopper Free Edition is still a great weapon in the war against annoying pop-up pests.
RoboForm might strike some as an odd choice for an encryption program, but it uses powerful encryption algorithms such as Blowfish and AES to protect your data. Combined with password generator technology, users choose one strong password instead of having to remember several. It reduces time spent filling out Web forms and logging onto subscription sites by remembering all your info.
You can set up multiple identities with different credit card numbers, passwords, and contact information. The trial limits the tab instances on each identity to three, but you can make plenty of identities. There's also search and hot-key support, and a one-click Login feature for submitting forms.
- Topics:
-
Security and spyware,
-
Windows Software
- Bookmark:
- Digg
- Del.icio.us


1. FIREWALL: According to matausec.com the best FREE firewall is Online Armor Personal, http://www.matousec.com/projects/windows-personal-firewall-analysis/leak-tests-results.php. Moreover, the screenshots provided here for Comodo are stale. The new version of Comodo is long out and differs significantly in terms of looks from the old one. Its a huge download as well and more resource hogging also.
2. ANTIVIRUS: According to av-test.org, av-comparatives.org, virusbtn.com, anyone can easily draw out the conclusion that the best free antivirus is Antivir and not AVG. In fact Avast is also better than AVG.The job of an Antivirus is to effectively fight malware. Even if Antivir`s updates are a bit sluggish, it more than makes up for that in terms of its superb detection rates. And here is an eye opener for all kaspersky, nod32, etc etc lovers: http://winnow.oitc.com/malewarestats.php. And please check your facts, Antivir explicitly states that its free version DOES NOT fight spyware.
3. ANTISPYWARE: Is this the best you could suggest: hijack this? I mean come on you are talking about a diagnostic tool which will come in handy after the spyware infection has occurred. What about preventing it in the first place? Spyware Terminator is the best free Active(i.e. it provides resident protection) Antispyware out there. It includes HIPS protection as well. If you dont need Active Antispyware protection then AVG Antispyware would be your best bet(its free version drops its resident protection after 30 days). You could also try PC Tools Spyware Doctor Starter Edition via the google pack, but its really resource intensive.
4. WEB SURFING ADVISOR: I agree that McAfee`s Site Advisor is a competetive product but there is something even better available for free. Its called Link Scanner Lite. You can actually make this software scan a link without actually visiting it, thereby providing realtime security rating, rather than some cyclic rating system which periodically checks out websites. It is essential because websites are being compromised everyday.
I expected a lot better than this from someone working for the security department in the high and mighty Download.com.
P.S. Did anyone tell you that McAfee`s VirusScan Plus is being offered for free via AOL? Its a huge tip for free software lovers. But apparently the author of this article doesnt think so or isnt aware of that.
I am feeling really sorry for all the people following this guide blindly.
avast is the best complete free anti virus
Also, the McAfee products are garbage almost across the board. SiteAdvisor, VirusScan, whatever...junk. Big slob programs that rarely stop anything and are nearly impossible to remove from you PC even by using their own removal tools. McAfee is consistently outperformed by MOST security programs pay or free. The only one that is consistently behind McAfee is Microsoft's OneCare program. McAfee used to be the FREE choice that most ISP's bundled with their service...most of them are now switching to other companies because McAfee is consistently failing in most independent reviews. With McAfee's detection rates consistently ranging between 20-80% I don't blame them.
Wanna stop spyware and adware COMPLETELY? Use Mozilla Firefox with AdBlockPlus and No Script. 99.9% of the junkware out there will be foiled by those 2 addons. Whatever gets by that will likely be stopped by Antivir. Run Ad-Aware and Spybot scans after 30 days of surfing with that setup and you will find only a few harmless cookies. You could stop those too by changing Firefox's cookie handling settings.
The best part of using the Firefox/Comodo/Antivir setup is that you only have to restart you PC maybe once a month (usually with the Windows Update)! Unlike the McAfees and Nortons where restarts are almost daily. Comodo rarely does updates and Antivir has coded their software to turn itself off during updates and then restarting it after the update has been applied. So many coders out there can learn from this program. And light on the system too. I think the lightest A/V program on the planet and ALWAYS among the highest detection rates as shown by your link to oitc.com.
I agree with you that HiJackThis does not belong in this review...it doesn't stop infestation. If you get to the point that you need HiJackThis, then just reformat. Use the 3 programs mentioned above and reformatting will only be needed after 2-3 years...as it should. More often of course on machines that spend alot of time in the "bad" internet neighborhoods. ;)
Anyway, good luck.
I do agree McAfee`s Site Advisor is good but Link Scanner Lite not good.
It took a lot of time to scan and it not very accurate rating SOMETIME OR AT ALL.....
Second: Anti spyware. I agree on you that Hijackthis is for sure not a good choice, but, Spyware doctor isn't either. It is full of false positives and the version from google has limited updates (like 400,000 out of 800,000). The best free anti spywares are SUPERAnti Spyware, AVG Anti spyware, and even Windows Defender is quite good. But, AVG Anti spyware updates are going down soon, but you can still use Ewido's Micro scanner which will continue to update, or start using an old version of Ewido anti spyware. About web surfing, I'm with you
................."1. FIREWALL: According to matausec.com the best FREE firewall is Online Armor Personal, http://www.matousec.com/projects/windows-personal-firewall-analysis/leak-tests-results.php. Moreover, the screenshots provided here for Comodo are stale. The new version of Comodo is long out and differs significantly in terms of looks from the old one. Its a huge download as well and more resource hogging also.".....................
By the way, I hope everyone who see this article have a good holiday.Merry Christmas!
the list is good enough, if not best. The editor here isn't on your payroll, so keep your darn facts with yourself. if you are so concerned about the credibility of this blog, go start your own blog and tell people what to do,there.
To be on "The best of 2007" list one doesn't need to be the best. All you need is the right contact and the means to persuade...
I am a bit surprised Ad-Aware 2007 isn't listed, although I found that version of Ad-Aware a big mess compared to the older SE Personal version.
1. Firewall: I agree, Comodo Firewall Pro is one of the best firewalls out there. I have to admit, i don't know about nothing about Online Armor, but definetely Comodo Firewall is the best.
2. Antivirus: First of all, AVG shouldn't be included because the program is too simple and doesn't have a web shield. Antivir is a good antivirus, even though is free, it provides pretty good protection compared to other paid products. Finally, avast! is a good antivirus and it should be included in the list. The program provides some the following features Mail, IM, Network, P2P, Web and Resident Protecion in the home edition.
3. Antispyware: HighJack this is a powerful antispyware program, but is recommended only for experience users. Definetely, Spyware Terminator should be considered because it provides resident protection for free. Second, Spybot Search & Destroy provides really good features and as Spyware Terminator is free. Last, Scanners should include AVG Antispyware, SuperAntispyware, Windows Defender and Ad-aware (the last two are not that good).
4. Web-surfing adviser: McAfee's SiteAdvisor is a must for all users. The other must is Link Scanner. The programs provides automatic real-time analysis of network traffic and web site content, and definetely should be included on the Security Starter Kit.
A good example is to test your Antivirus. Lets try something that will not harm your PC, but it will let you know if your AV is protecting you.
EICAR: is just an anti-virus or anti-malware test, it will tell you if your antivirus y working properly.
Here is the link: http://www.eicar.org/anti_virus_test_file.htm
and if you don't trust the website watch this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SFU0atEKXKw
At the end, just test AVG with the EICAR file and we'll see.
Thank You
1. Default Vista firewall
2. avast! Home Edition (but Antivir piqued my interest)
3. Spyware Terminator
4. McAfee SiteAdvisor
i don't consider myself a safe user when it comes to web surfing but i never got any malwares (yet).
my 2cents.
P.S. To CNET editors. I don't know what has been going on over the past year or so but the reviews of software have become very one sided and not very well researched. I was able to find multple testing sites that show that many of recommendations are not the best. Also like in the case of AVG you have been recommending the software for a very long time but threats are constantly changing and so is the software to fight them and like AVG they can not continue to upgrade the product forever and still be the best. But CNET keeps recommending the same product over and over again when it has "fallen behind the times". Please try to do a better job in research or your recommendations will considered sponsor paid for than true creditable and helpful information.
McAfee's 3-1 VirusScan from http://daol.aol.com/software/ (firewall, anti-spyware, and antivirus)
Firefox Browser with the NoScript plug-in
McAfee's Site Advisor
Nothing will ever provide 100% protection, but I feel very secure with this software.
-
by weeny-enid
December 30, 2007 5:37 PM PST
- very good
-
Reply to this comment
-
See all 95 Comments >>